Education Costs on the Rise: Is Post-Secondary Education Becoming Out of Reach?

The cost of post-secondary education (PSE) in Alberta is escalating, raising concerns about its accessibility for students and the potential repercussions for the province's future workforce. This article examines the historical trends of rising education costs in Alberta, compares them with other provinces and countries, and investigates the underlying reasons for these increases. It further explores the consequences of this trend on students, including financial stress and student debt, and its potential implications for Alberta's future workforce, including skill shortages and economic competitiveness. Finally, the article explores potential solutions and initiatives to address this pressing issue.

Historical Trends in Tuition Fees and Related Expenses

Tuition fees for post-secondary institutions in Alberta have been steadily climbing over the past few decades. Data from the University of Alberta Students' Union reveals a marked increase in tuition for undergraduate degrees, particularly between 1990 and 2010 1. While there was a slight dip in tuition fees after 2010, they have resumed their upward trajectory, with the highest recorded cost in 2011 at $7,225 (in constant 2019 dollars) 1. This trend aligns with the national trend in Canada, where Alberta has generally remained close to the Canadian average for undergraduate tuition fees 2.

More specifically, tuition for a Bachelor of Arts degree in Alberta has also seen a steady increase. Between 1980 and 1990, tuition remained relatively stable, but from 1990 to 2000, there was a consistent rise. Following a slight dip in the early 2000s, tuition has continued to increase, reaching $7,114 in 2022 1.

Adding to the financial burden, domestic students at the University of Alberta faced a 5.5% tuition increase in the 2023/24 academic year 3. This increase comes before the implementation of a 2% tuition cap starting in 2024/25, highlighting the challenges students face in managing the escalating cost of education.

In addition to tuition fees, other related expenses, such as accommodation, books, and transportation, have also been on the rise. Although specific historical data on these expenses is limited, the general increase in the cost of living, as reflected in the Consumer Price Index (CPI), suggests an upward trend in these costs 4. The CPI, which measures the average change in prices paid by consumers for a basket of goods and services, provides an indication of the rising cost of living in Alberta, impacting students' overall expenses 5.

Comparing Education Costs: Alberta, Canada, and the World

While Alberta's tuition fees have generally followed the national average, they are still higher than in some provinces. In 2023, the average cost of a four-year university degree in Alberta was $78,034, ranking fifth among Canadian provinces 6. This cost is slightly higher than the national average and significantly more than the most affordable province, Newfoundland and Labrador, where a four-year degree costs $54,366 6.

Furthermore, international students in Alberta face even higher tuition fees and compulsory fees compared to their domestic counterparts 7. This disparity adds to the financial burden on international students seeking higher education in Alberta.

Graduate students also experience significant costs. In 2022/2023, graduate students in Alberta faced the highest additional compulsory fees ($1,170) among Canadian provinces, exceeding the national average by approximately 16.9% 7. This highlights the financial challenges faced by graduate students pursuing advanced degrees in Alberta.

To better illustrate the variations in education costs, the following table provides a comparison of average tuition fees and other expenses across different provinces and countries:

Province/Country

Average Tuition Fee

Other Expenses

Alberta

$7,734 (domestic undergraduate in 2024/25) 8

Accommodation, books, transportation (not specified)

Nova Scotia

$9,762 (domestic undergraduate in 2024/25) 8

Not specified

Newfoundland and Labrador

$3,727 (domestic undergraduate in 2024/25) 8

Not specified

Canada

$7,360 (domestic undergraduate in 2024/25) 8

Not specified

Japan

$5,144 (bachelor's degree) 9

Not specified

United States

Varies by institution 10

Varies by institution

This table provides a snapshot of the variations in education costs, but it's important to note that these figures represent averages and can vary significantly depending on the institution, program of study, and individual circumstances.

Detailed International Comparison

To further understand Alberta's position in the global education landscape, it's crucial to examine education expenditures per full-time-equivalent (FTE) student in different countries. In 2019, the United States spent $15,500 per FTE student on elementary and secondary education, exceeding the average of Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) member countries ($11,300) by 38% 10. At the post-secondary level, the United States spent $37,400 per FTE student, more than double the OECD average ($18,400) 10. These figures highlight the significant investment made by the United States in education.

In comparison, Canada's spending on education is relatively lower. While specific data for Canada's expenditure per FTE student is not available in the provided sources, it's important to note that Canada's overall expenditure on education as a percentage of GDP is lower than that of the United States 11. This suggests that Canada invests comparatively less in education compared to the United States.

Factors Driving the Rise in Education Costs

Several factors contribute to the rising cost of post-secondary education in Alberta. One significant factor is the reduction in government funding for post-secondary institutions. Over the past five years, Alberta has experienced a 31% cut in funding for post-secondary education 12. This decline in government support has forced institutions to increase tuition fees to compensate for the funding shortfall 13.

Adding to this challenge, research funding within higher education as a share of GDP is also declining 14. This decline in research funding could potentially impact the quality and competitiveness of Alberta's post-secondary institutions, further exacerbating the challenges posed by rising education costs.

However, it's important to consider expert opinions on this issue. The Fraser Institute argues that simply increasing government spending on education does not necessarily translate to better student performance 15. They cite Alberta's relatively high student performance on international tests despite having lower per-student spending compared to other provinces as evidence for their argument.

Despite these varying perspectives, a key insight emerges: there is a disconnect between government rhetoric and the reality of affordability in Alberta's post-secondary education system. While the government may claim to be a "big spender" on education, Alberta actually ranks last in per-student spending among Canadian provinces 16. This underfunding, coupled with provincial budget constraints 17, has led to an increased reliance on tuition increases to fund post-secondary education, ultimately shifting the burden to students and their families.

Another contributing factor to rising education costs is the increasing cost of operating post-secondary institutions. Factors such as inflation, IT modernization, and evolving student service demands have led to higher operating expenditures for universities 18. These increased costs are ultimately passed on to students through higher tuition fees 18.

Furthermore, Alberta's population growth, particularly among youth and immigrants, has put pressure on post-secondary institutions to expand their capacity 19. This expansion requires significant investment in infrastructure and resources, which can contribute to rising education costs.

Potential Solutions and Initiatives

Addressing the rising cost of post-secondary education requires a multi-faceted approach involving the government, institutions, and students. One potential solution is to increase government funding for post-secondary institutions. Restoring funding to pre-cut levels and implementing a funding formula that accounts for enrollment growth and inflation could help alleviate the financial pressure on institutions and students 20.

In this context, it's worth noting that Budget 2024 includes increased funding for post-secondary institutions' operating expenses and focuses on funding seats in high-demand areas to address skill shortages 21. While this is a positive step, it remains to be seen how effectively this increased funding will address the long-term challenges of affordability and accessibility in post-secondary education.

Another approach is to expand access to needs-based grants and scholarships. Increasing the availability of non-repayable financial aid can reduce students' reliance on loans and minimize debt burdens 20. The University of Alberta, for example, awards over $40 million in undergraduate scholarships to continuing students each year, and the University of Alberta Students' Union also offers awards to support students 22. Promoting and expanding such initiatives can play a crucial role in making education more affordable.

Furthermore, promoting alternative pathways to post-secondary education, such as apprenticeships and co-op programs, can provide students with opportunities to gain valuable skills and earn income while pursuing their education 23. Co-op programs, in particular, offer students the chance to gain work experience, make industry contacts, and earn money to help pay for their education 23.

The government has also taken some steps to address student financial difficulties. These include a 2% cap on tuition fee increases, an increase in the income threshold for student loan repayment assistance from $25,000 to $40,000, and an extension of the interest-free grace period from 6 to 12 months 24. While these measures provide some relief, a more comprehensive and long-term strategy is needed to address the systemic challenges of rising education costs.

In addition to these initiatives, exploring innovative solutions like the zero-fee post-secondary education program in Drayton Valley could offer valuable lessons for Alberta 25. This program aims to diversify the local economy and provide residents with accessible educational opportunities by removing financial barriers 25. Studying the implementation and impact of such programs can provide insights into alternative approaches to funding and delivering post-secondary education.

To ensure a comprehensive review of post-secondary funding, the government has established the Expert Panel on Post-Secondary Institution Funding and Alberta's Competitiveness 26. This panel is tasked with reviewing provincial funding models, exploring alternative funding mechanisms, and assessing Alberta's ability to compete globally in higher education 26. The panel's recommendations are expected to provide valuable guidance for shaping future policies and ensuring the long-term sustainability and effectiveness of Alberta's post-secondary education system.

However, it's crucial to recognize the potential impact of tuition caps on university budgets. With limited tuition increases, universities face challenges in balancing their budgets and maintaining the quality of education 27. This highlights the need for exploring alternative funding sources and ensuring that universities have the resources to provide a high-quality learning experience.

Furthermore, it's essential to consider student perspectives on tuition increases. Students are increasingly concerned about the value for money they receive in relation to rising tuition fees and the impact on their financial well-being 27. Addressing these concerns requires transparent communication from institutions about how tuition fees are used and demonstrating a commitment to providing students with a valuable and affordable education.

Implications for Alberta's Future Workforce

The rising cost of post-secondary education has potential long-term implications for Alberta's future workforce. One concern is the potential for skill shortages. As education becomes less accessible, fewer individuals may pursue higher education, leading to a shortage of skilled workers in critical sectors 29. This shortage could hinder economic growth and innovation.

Adding to this challenge, the landscape of skills is rapidly evolving due to automation and artificial intelligence (AI) 14. This necessitates upskilling and reskilling for workers to remain competitive in the job market, further emphasizing the importance of accessible and affordable post-secondary education.

Moreover, the growing importance of lifelong learning cannot be overlooked 14. As individuals need to adapt to changing job market demands, accessible and flexible learning options become crucial for career development and economic success.

Reduced access to higher education could also exacerbate social inequalities. Students from lower-income families may be disproportionately affected by rising costs, limiting their opportunities for upward mobility and contributing to a widening gap between the rich and the poor 30. This is particularly concerning for first-generation students who often face greater financial challenges, including higher reliance on loans and lower access to family support 30.

Furthermore, the increasing cost of education could impact Alberta's economic competitiveness. As students face higher debt burdens, they may be less likely to take risks, start businesses, or invest in their future, potentially hindering economic development and innovation 28. This is particularly relevant in the context of Alberta's economic performance, which has faced challenges in recent years 31.

To illustrate the extent of the skills shortage, it's worth noting that Alberta's job vacancy rate, particularly in the construction sector, is significantly high 32. This shortage of skilled workers could hinder the province's economic recovery and its ability to support major projects, highlighting the urgent need to address the accessibility and affordability of education and training programs.

In addition to the economic consequences, rising education costs can have long-term social implications. Students facing financial strain may delay family formation and have limited career choices, potentially impacting their overall well-being and contributing to broader societal challenges 33.

It's also important to consider the intergenerational impact of rising education costs. As post-secondary education becomes increasingly expensive, future generations may face even greater barriers to accessing higher education, potentially perpetuating socioeconomic disparities and limiting opportunities for social mobility 34.

Conclusion

The rising cost of post-secondary education in Alberta presents a significant challenge with potential long-term consequences for students and the province's future workforce. While recent government initiatives, such as increased funding in Budget 2024 and measures to address student financial difficulties, offer some relief, a more comprehensive and long-term strategy is needed to ensure that post-secondary education remains accessible and affordable for all.

This strategy should prioritize increased government funding for institutions, expanded access to needs-based financial aid, and the promotion of alternative pathways to education. It should also address the evolving skills landscape, the growing importance of lifelong learning, and the need to mitigate the social and economic consequences of rising education costs.

Ultimately, a sustainable and effective post-secondary education system is crucial for Alberta's social and economic prosperity. By investing in education and ensuring its accessibility for all, Alberta can foster a skilled and adaptable workforce, promote innovation, and build a more equitable and prosperous future for all its citizens.

Works cited

1. www.su.ualberta.ca, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.su.ualberta.ca/media/uploads/1143/Undergraduate%20Tuition%20Trends%20in%20Canada%20and%20Alberta.pdf

2. PSE in Alberta – Part 2 | HESA - Higher Education Strategy Associates, accessed December 30, 2024, https://higheredstrategy.com/pse-in-alberta-part-2/

3. Government of Alberta Announces 2% Tuition Increases Starting in 2024/25 After Years of Severe Tuition Hikes - Students' Union, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.su.ualberta.ca/about/news/entry/394/government-of-alberta-announces-2-tuition-increases-starting-in-202425-after-years-of-severe-tuition-hikes/

4. Consumer price index - Alberta Economic Dashboard, accessed December 30, 2024, https://economicdashboard.alberta.ca/dashboard/consumer-price-index/

5. Consumer Price Index, Year-Over-Year Percentage Change, Canada and Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://open.alberta.ca/opendata/consumer-price-index-year-over-year-percentage-change-canada-and-alberta

6. Cost of four-year degree in Alberta rises to over $78K: report | Lethbridge News Now, accessed December 30, 2024, https://lethbridgenewsnow.com/2023/11/10/cost-of-four-year-degree-in-alberta-rises-to-over-78k-report/

7. Tuition fees for degree programs, 2022/2023, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/daily-quotidien/220907/dq220907b-eng.pdf

8. What Is the Average Tuition in Canada for 2025? - Robertson College, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.robertsoncollege.com/blog/studying-at-robertson/average-tuition-in-canada/

9. How college tuition in the US compares to the rest of the world - Triad City Beat, accessed December 30, 2024, https://triad-city-beat.com/how-college-tuition-in-the-us-compares-to-the-rest-of-the-world/

10. COE - Education Expenditures by Country, accessed December 30, 2024, https://nces.ed.gov/programs/coe/indicator/cmd/education-expenditures-by-country

11. International comparisons of expenditures for education, accessed December 30, 2024, https://nces.ed.gov/pubs98/98009.pdf

12. The political battle over postsecondary education in Alberta - University Affairs, accessed December 30, 2024, https://universityaffairs.ca/features/the-political-battle-over-postsecondary-education-in-alberta/

13. News - Students' Union - University of Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www2.su.ualberta.ca/about/news/entry/382/the-alberta-disadvantage-31-drop-in-funding-to-albertas-post-secondary-education/

14. Alberta 2030: Building Skills for Jobs, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.alberta.ca/system/files/custom_downloaded_images/ae-ab2030-analysis-and-stakeholder-input.pdf

15. More money not the answer for schools—just look at Alberta | Fraser Institute, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.fraserinstitute.org/commentary/more-money-not-answer-schools-just-look-alberta

16. Alberta ranks last in education spending, accessed December 30, 2024, https://teachers.ab.ca/news/alberta-ranks-last-education-spending

17. The 2024 Provincial Budget and What It Means for Us - The Flame Blog - University of Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://theflame.su.ualberta.ca/en/blog/2024/03/01/the-2024-provincial-budget-and-what-it-means-for-us/

18. Alberta 2030 Recommendations - Students' Union, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.su.ualberta.ca/media/uploads/1143/UASUAlberta2030.pdf

19. A New Alberta Postsecondary Review | HESA - Higher Education Strategy Associates, accessed December 30, 2024, https://higheredstrategy.com/a-new-alberta-postsecondary-review/

20. Better Way Alberta: - POST-SECONDARY EDUCATION, accessed December 30, 2024, https://betterwayalberta.ca/wp-content/uploads/2022/10/BWA_IssueReport_PSE_V04.pdf

21. BREAKING: Budget 2024's impact on Alberta post-secondary education - The Gateway, accessed December 30, 2024, https://thegatewayonline.ca/2024/02/breaking-budget-2024s-impact-on-alberta-post-secondary-education/

22. Tuition Increases | Office of the Registrar - University of Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.ualberta.ca/en/registrar/costs-tuition-fees/tuition-increases.html

23. Work and Save Money to Pay for School - alis - Government of Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://alis.alberta.ca/explore-education-and-training/pay-for-your-education/work-and-save-money-to-pay-for-school/

24. 12 Ways to Pay Off Alberta Student Loans Fast - Money Mentors, accessed December 30, 2024, https://moneymentors.ca/money-tips/ways-to-pay-off-student-loans-fast/

25. Examining the Outcomes of Zero-Fee Education in Building a Resilient, Inclusive Economy in Rural Alberta - Future Skills Centre, accessed December 30, 2024, https://fsc-ccf.ca/projects/zerofee-edu/

26. Expert Panel on Post-Secondary Institution Funding and Alberta's Competitiveness, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.alberta.ca/expert-panel-on-post-secondary-institution-funding-and-albertas-competitiveness

27. U of A students raise tuition concerns at tuition town hall - The Gateway, accessed December 30, 2024, https://thegatewayonline.ca/2024/11/u-of-a-students-raise-tuition-concerns-at-tuition-town-hall/

28. High post-secondary expenses leave Alberta college students in a pinch | Globalnews.ca, accessed December 30, 2024, https://globalnews.ca/news/10729564/alberta-post-secondary-tuition-costs/

29. Job market forecasts | Alberta.ca, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.alberta.ca/job-market-forecasts

30. Provincial Budget Impacts on Students Overview - Students' Union - University of Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.su.ualberta.ca/media/uploads/1143/Provincial%20Budget%20Impacts%20on%20Students%20-%20November%202019.pdf

31. Alberta's Economy - Economic Overview - FULL REPORT, accessed December 30, 2024, https://www.businesscouncilab.com/wp-content/uploads/2021/12/Albertas-Economy-Economic-Overview-FULL.pdf

32. Stretched Thin: Labour Supply in the Skilled Trades | Business Council of Alberta, accessed December 30, 2024, https://businesscouncilab.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/10/Stretched-Thin-Labour-Supply-in-the-Skilled-Trades-DISTRIBUTION.pdf

33. Should Post-Secondary Education be Free? - Alberta Views, accessed December 30, 2024, https://albertaviews.ca/post-secondary-education-free-tuition/

34. Alberta post-secondary students pay more tuition than national average: report | CTV News, accessed December 30, 2024, https://calgary.ctvnews.ca/alberta-post-secondary-students-pay-more-tuition-than-national-average-report-1.6638846