Retirement Security in Alberta: Are Albertans Prepared for the Future?

Retirement security is a growing concern for individuals and governments across Canada as the population ages and life expectancy increases 1. Ensuring adequate retirement income becomes crucial for maintaining financial stability and well-being in later life. This report delves into the retirement savings landscape in Alberta, analyzing the challenges faced by seniors and exploring the need for robust pension plans and retirement income support.

Retirement Savings and Income Levels of Seniors in Alberta

Retirement planning in Alberta involves a mix of government-funded programs, employer-sponsored pension plans, and individual savings. The average amount held in Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) in Alberta was $157,405 in 2022 2. However, the median RRSP contribution per year is only $7,054 3. While these figures provide a snapshot of retirement savings, they don't fully capture the complexity of the situation. It is important to note that most Canadians, including Albertans, are likely behind in their retirement savings, highlighting the need for increased awareness and action to ensure a financially secure retirement 4.

The median after-tax income for senior households in Canada, where the highest income earner is 65 or older, is $61,200 6. However, this figure varies significantly based on individual circumstances, including marital status, health, and access to employer-sponsored pensions.

Pension Plans Available to Albertans

Albertans have access to various pension plans, each with its own characteristics and implications for retirement income:

• Defined Benefit (DB) Pension Plans: These plans provide a guaranteed income stream in retirement, typically calculated based on years of service and average earnings. Retirees who are members of a DB pension plan report higher satisfaction with life compared to those with defined contribution plans or no pension plan 7. Examples of DB plans available to Albertans include:

• Private sector employment pensions: These are established by private sector employers for their employees8.

• Public sector employment pensions: These cover employees working in the public sector, including provincial and municipal public service, health, and education8.

• Defined Contribution (DC) Pension Plans: In these plans, both the employee and employer contribute to an individual account, and the retirement income depends on the investment performance of the funds. Examples include:

• Group Registered Retirement Savings Plans (RRSPs) 9

• Pooled Registered Pension Plans (PRPPs) 9

• Federal retirement income programs: These include the Canada Pension Plan (CPP) and Old Age Security (OAS), which provide a foundation for retirement income for all Canadians8.

Eligibility criteria and contribution limits vary across these plans. For instance, to be eligible for a full CPP retirement pension, individuals must be 65 years old or older 10. Contribution rates for the CPP in 2025 are 5.95% for employees and employers each, with a maximum annual employee contribution of $4,034.10 11.

Government Support Programs for Seniors in Alberta

The Alberta government offers several programs to support seniors' financial well-being, in addition to the federal programs and employer-sponsored pension plans. These programs are summarized in the table below:

Program Name

Description

Eligibility Criteria

Alberta Seniors Benefit (ASB)

Provides a monthly benefit to help with living expenses.

Age 65 or older, resident of Alberta for at least 3 months, low income.

Supplementary Accommodation Benefit

Offers financial assistance for seniors residing in designated supportive living or long-term care homes.

Age 65 or older, resident of Alberta for at least 3 months, low income, residing in a designated facility.

Special Needs Assistance for Seniors

Provides financial aid for appliances and specific health and personal supports.

Age 65 or older, resident of Alberta for at least 3 months, low income.

Dental and Optical Assistance for Seniors

Offers financial assistance for basic dental and optical services.

Age 65 or older, resident of Alberta for at least 3 months, low to moderate income.

Seniors Home Adaptation and Repair Program

Helps finance home repairs and renovations through a low-interest home equity loan.

Age 65 or older, homeowner, meeting certain income and equity requirements.

Alberta Seniors Benefit Program

Provides support in addition to federal benefits received under Old Age Security, Guaranteed Income Supplement, Federal Allowance, and the GST credit.

Based on income and provides monthly benefits to eligible seniors.

These programs aim to alleviate financial burdens and improve the quality of life for seniors in Alberta8.

Retirement Security Concerns in Alberta

Various stakeholders, including unions and advocacy groups, have raised concerns about retirement security in Alberta. These concerns primarily revolve around potential changes to the pension system and the need to protect the retirement income of Albertans.

• The Alberta government's proposed changes to the Alberta Investment Management Corporation (AIMCo) have raised concerns about potential political interference in pension fund management and the security of retirement savings14.

• Unions have expressed concerns about the potential impact of government policies on the retirement security of their members, emphasizing the importance of joint governance models in protecting pension funds15.

• Advocacy groups have voiced concerns about the potential risks associated with Alberta's proposed withdrawal from the CPP, highlighting the need to safeguard the retirement income of Albertans16.

These concerns underscore the importance of open dialogue and collaboration among stakeholders to ensure that any changes to the pension system prioritize the long-term financial well-being of Albertans.

Challenges Faced by Seniors in Alberta

Despite the availability of pension plans and support programs, seniors in Alberta face various challenges to their retirement security:

Financial Challenges:

• Inadequate retirement savings: Many Albertans lack sufficient savings to maintain their living standards in retirement17.

• Rising cost of living: Inflation, particularly in housing and healthcare, erodes the value of retirement savings and fixed incomes. Seniors in Alberta are disproportionately affected by inflation due to their spending patterns, which include higher expenses on housing and healthcare, and their reliance on fixed incomes 18.

• Poverty: A significant portion of seniors in Alberta live below the poverty line, highlighting the financial vulnerability of this segment of the population. In 2021, the poverty rate for seniors in Alberta was 5.6% 20.

Healthcare Challenges:

• Healthcare costs: As people age, healthcare expenses tend to increase, putting a strain on retirement budgets21.

• Long-term care costs: The cost of long-term care can be substantial, and many seniors struggle to afford quality care17.

• Access to quality care: Challenges in Alberta's seniors care facilities, such as low staff-to-resident ratios, can impact the quality of care available to seniors22.

Other Challenges:

• Elder abuse: Financial abuse is a significant concern for seniors, with an estimated one in ten Alberta seniors potentially being victims23.

Addressing these challenges requires a multi-pronged approach that includes promoting retirement savings, providing adequate income support, ensuring access to affordable healthcare, and protecting seniors from financial abuse.

Expert Opinions and Analysis

Experts have expressed diverse opinions and analyses regarding the retirement savings landscape in Alberta and the potential implications of proposed changes to the pension system.

• Concerns about CPP withdrawal: Some experts warn that Alberta's proposal to withdraw from the CPP could jeopardize retirement security for Albertans, citing potential risks and complexities associated with establishing a new provincial plan24.

• Potential benefits of an APP: Other experts suggest that an Alberta Pension Plan (APP) could offer benefits to Albertans, such as lower contribution rates, higher benefits, and stronger benefit security due to a large asset transfer from the CPP and a younger demographic in Alberta 25. However, they also caution against potential pitfalls and the need for careful consideration.

These varying perspectives highlight the need for a thorough and objective assessment of the potential impacts of any changes to the pension system.

Initiatives and Policies Aimed at Improving Retirement Security

The Alberta government has undertaken several initiatives and policies aimed at enhancing retirement security in the province:

• Alberta Pension Protection Act: This act requires a referendum on establishing an APP before any changes to the CPP can be made. It guarantees that Albertans would pay the same or lower contribution rates and receive the same or better benefits under an APP compared to the CPP27.

• Potential cost savings of an APP: The proposed APP is projected to generate significant cost savings, estimated at $5 billion in the first year alone. These savings could be used to enhance pension benefits for seniors or reduce contribution rates for workers26.

• Increased CPP benefits: The federal and provincial governments have agreed to enhance CPP benefits, with contribution rates gradually increasing to support these enhancements28.

These initiatives reflect a commitment to strengthening retirement security in Alberta, but ongoing evaluation and adaptation are crucial to ensure their effectiveness in meeting the evolving needs of the aging population.

Comparison to Other Provinces

Compared to other Canadian provinces, Alberta has a relatively younger population and higher average incomes, resulting in higher contributions to the CPP 29. This has fueled debate about whether an APP would be more beneficial for Albertans. However, experts caution against potential risks and complexities associated with withdrawing from the CPP 30.

Furthermore, the traditional 70% income replacement rate used to assess retirement income adequacy may not be an accurate measure, prompting a discussion on how to better evaluate retirement readiness and tailor retirement planning strategies to individual circumstances 31.

Conclusion

Retirement security in Alberta is a multifaceted issue with no easy solutions. While the province offers various pension plans and support programs, challenges remain in ensuring adequate retirement income for all Albertans. The debate surrounding the proposed APP highlights the need for careful consideration of the potential benefits and risks associated with any changes to the pension system.

Key findings from this report indicate that:

• Many Albertans may have inadequate retirement savings to maintain their living standards in retirement.

• Seniors in Alberta face various challenges, including rising living costs, healthcare expenses, and potential financial abuse.

• The proposed APP has the potential to offer benefits such as lower contribution rates and higher benefits, but also carries potential risks and complexities.

To improve retirement security in Alberta, policymakers and individuals can consider the following recommendations:

• Policymakers:

• Promote financial literacy and retirement planning education to encourage early and consistent savings.

• Ensure the long-term sustainability of pension plans and government support programs.

• Address the rising cost of living, particularly in housing and healthcare, to protect the value of retirement income.

• Strengthen measures to prevent elder abuse, including financial abuse.

• Explore options for improving retirement income adequacy, considering factors beyond the traditional 70% income replacement rate.

• Individuals:

• Start saving for retirement early and contribute consistently to retirement savings plans.

• Develop a comprehensive retirement plan that considers individual circumstances and goals.

• Seek professional financial advice to optimize retirement planning strategies.

• Stay informed about pension plans, government programs, and retirement planning options.

Ultimately, a comprehensive approach that addresses the diverse needs of Alberta's aging population is crucial for securing a financially stable future for seniors. This includes promoting individual responsibility, providing adequate social safety nets, and fostering collaboration among stakeholders to ensure a secure and dignified retirement for all Albertans.

Works cited

1. HillStudy: Canada's Retirement Income System - Library of Parliament, accessed January 5, 2025, https://lop.parl.ca/staticfiles/PublicWebsite/Home/ResearchPublications/HillStudies/PDF/2019-40-E.pdf

2. BMO Annual Retirement Study: Canadians Believe They Need $1.7M to Retire - Up 20 Per Cent from 2020, accessed January 5, 2025, https://newsroom.bmo.com/2023-02-07-BMO-Annual-Retirement-Study-Canadians-Believe-They-Need-1-7M-to-Retire-Up-20-Per-Cent-from-2020

3. How much do you need to retire comfortably in Canada? - PolicyAdvisor, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.policyadvisor.com/magazine/how-much-do-i-need-to-retire/

4. How much do Canadians need to save per year for retirement?, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.fidelity.ca/en/insights/articles/how-much-canadians-save-for-retirement/

5. How much do you need to retire in Canada? - Bloom Finance, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.bloomfin.ca/posts/how-much-do-you-need-to-retire-in-canada

6. Average Canadian retirement income | Wealthsimple, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.wealthsimple.com/en-ca/learn/average-retirement-income-canada

7. of Public Pension Plans in Alberta 2021 Social Value Benefits, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.pspp.ca/assets/pspp/files/documents/posts/social%20value%20benefits%20of%20public%20pension%20plans%20in%20alberta_cancea_july25_2022....pdf

8. www.alberta.ca, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.alberta.ca/about-pensions-news-links

9. Employer pension plans - Canada.ca, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.canada.ca/en/financial-consumer-agency/services/retirement-planning/employer-sponsored-pension.html

10. Canada Pension Plan - Eligibility, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.canada.ca/en/services/benefits/publicpensions/cpp/cpp-benefit/eligibility.html

11. Canada Pension Plan - Your Alberta CPA, accessed January 5, 2025, http://youralbertacpa.com/canada-pension-plan/

12. Government of Alberta - Ministry of Seniors, Community, and Social Services - Seniors Financial Assistance Programs, accessed January 5, 2025, https://ab.211.ca/record/1086046/

13. Seniors financial assistance programs | Alberta.ca, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.alberta.ca/seniors-financial-assistance

14. CUPE Alberta responds to continued Alberta government interference in Public Sector Pension Plan, accessed January 5, 2025, https://cupe.ca/cupe-alberta-responds-continued-alberta-government-interference-public-sector-pension-plan

15. UNA stands proudly behind its fight to protect members' retirement security, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.una.ca/1487/una-stands-proudly-behind-its-fight-to-protect-members-retirement-security-

16. Save Our CPP - PIA New - Public Interest Alberta, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.pialberta.org/saveourcpp

17. STRIKE a Change for Alberta Seniors - AUPE, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.aupe.org/news-and-publications/campaigns/strike-change-alberta-seniors

18. Is Inflation Higher for Seniors?, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11-621-m/11-621-m2005027-eng.pdf

19. High inflation putting extra strain on seniors: advocacy group - Healthy Aging CORE Alberta, accessed January 5, 2025, https://corealberta.ca/news/high-inflation-putting-extra-strain-on-seniors-advocacy-group

20. Question Period Note: Poverty among Seniors in Canada - Open Government Portal, accessed January 5, 2025, https://search.open.canada.ca/qpnotes/record/esdc-edsc,Seniors_June2023_011

21. Aging population will put more pressure on Alberta's provincial finances | Fraser Institute, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.fraserinstitute.org/commentary/aging-population-will-put-more-pressure-albertas-provincial-finances

22. Key Challenges Facing Workers in Alberta's Seniors Care Facilities. - Teamsters 987, accessed January 5, 2025, https://teamsters987.com/key-challenges-facing-workers-in-albertas-seniors-care-facilities/

23. Elder abuse prevention strategy | Alberta.ca, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.alberta.ca/elder-abuse-prevention-strategy

24. Experts warn Alberta's pension plan proposal could conceal risks, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com/news/industry-news/experts-warn-albertas-pension-plan-proposal-could-conceal-risks/379971

25. Pension expert concerned about CPP if Alberta creates its own pension plan, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.benefitsandpensionsmonitor.com/news/industry-news/pension-expert-concerned-about-cpp-if-alberta-creates-its-own-pension-plan/382061

26. The Report | Understanding an Alberta Pension Plan, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.albertapensionplan.ca/the-report

27. Pensions – Legislation and updates | Alberta.ca, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.alberta.ca/pensions-legislation-updates

28. Canada Pension Plan enhancement, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.canada.ca/en/services/benefits/publicpensions/cpp/cpp-enhancement.html

29. Debate continues over an Alberta pension plan—but here's a key fact | Fraser Institute, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.fraserinstitute.org/commentary/debate-continues-over-alberta-pension-plan-heres-key-fact

30. Pension Roulette: The Risks and Consequences of Alberta Leaving the CPP, accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.cdhowe.org/publication/pension-roulette-risks-and-consequences-alberta-leaving-cpp/

31. Retirement Income Adequacy: A conversation for Canadians - Eckler Ltd., accessed January 5, 2025, https://www.eckler.ca/retirement-income-adequacy-a-conversation-for-canadians/