The Impact of Automation on Jobs in Alberta: Will Robots Replace Workers?

Automation is rapidly changing the nature of work across the globe, and Alberta is no exception1. While automation can bring significant benefits, such as increased productivity and efficiency, it also raises concerns about potential job displacement and the need for workforce adaptation. This report analyzes the potential impact of automation on employment in Alberta, identifies the industries most susceptible, and explores the crucial role of workforce development and retraining programs in navigating this technological shift.

The Rise of Automation: A Global Perspective

Automation, in its various forms, has been a driving force in economic and societal transformation for centuries. From the mechanization of agriculture to the rise of industrial robots, technological advancements have consistently reshaped industries and labor markets. Today, with the rapid development of artificial intelligence (AI), machine learning, and robotics, automation is poised to impact a wider range of jobs than ever before.

Studies suggest that a significant portion of the workforce is at risk of being affected by automation in the coming decades2. This includes jobs that involve routine, repetitive tasks, as well as those requiring cognitive skills that can be replicated by AI2. While automation can lead to increased productivity and economic growth, it also has the potential to exacerbate inequality and displace workers2.

To understand the scope of automation, it's helpful to consider its various types and components:

Automation Type

Components

Fixed Automation

Specialized equipment for high-volume production with minimal flexibility.

Programmable Automation

Equipment that can be reprogrammed to produce different products or parts.

Flexible Automation

Highly adaptable systems that can handle a variety of tasks and product variations.

Integrated Automation

Fully automated systems with interconnected components and minimal human intervention.

Automation in Canada: A National Context

In Canada, the impact of automation is already being felt across various sectors. A study by Statistics Canada found that 10.6% of Canadian workers were at high risk of automation-related job transformation in 2016, with another 29.1% facing moderate risk4. These figures highlight the need for proactive measures to address the potential challenges of automation.

The Alberta Centre for Labour Market Research (ACLMR) plays a vital role in providing labor market expertise and research to inform policy decisions in Alberta5. The ACLMR offers valuable resources and connects researchers with experts to help understand labor market trends, including the impact of automation.

The Canadian labor market has seen a shift towards occupations that require non-routine cognitive and manual tasks, while those involving routine tasks have declined6. This trend suggests that workers with higher levels of education and skills in areas such as critical thinking, problem-solving, and communication will be better positioned to adapt to the changing demands of the labor market.

Automation's Impact on Alberta: A Provincial Focus

Alberta's economy, traditionally reliant on natural resources, is particularly vulnerable to the effects of automation. The oil and gas sector, a major employer in the province, has already witnessed significant job losses due to automation and other factors7. A report by Ernst & Young predicts that automation could lead to further job losses in the Canadian upstream oil and gas sector by 20407.

A localized assessment of businesses in central Alberta revealed that while most businesses recognize the potential benefits of automation, such as improved efficiency, they also express concerns about the costs, the need to keep up with technological advancements, and the potential for job losses8. These businesses also highlighted the need for future skills, including adaptability and preparedness for technological change.

However, automation is not limited to the energy sector. Industries such as manufacturing, transportation, and logistics are also susceptible to automation9. As companies seek to improve efficiency and reduce costs, they are increasingly adopting automated systems and AI-powered technologies.

Industries Most at Risk in Alberta

While automation has the potential to impact various sectors in Alberta, some industries are more susceptible than others. These include:

• Oil and Gas: The oil and gas sector has already experienced significant job losses due to automation7. As technology advances, further automation in areas such as drilling, extraction, and processing is likely to occur. This sector will require workers with strong data literacy and technical proficiency in AI and automation technologies10. Moreover, repetitive and manual tasks within the sector are at higher risk of being automated11.

• Manufacturing: Manufacturing is another industry where automation is expected to have a significant impact. Robots and automated systems can perform tasks such as assembly, welding, and packaging with greater speed and precision than humans10.

• Transportation and Logistics: The rise of autonomous vehicles and drones has the potential to disrupt the transportation and logistics sector. Self-driving trucks and delivery drones could automate tasks currently performed by truck drivers and delivery personnel9.

The Skills Gap and the Need for Workforce Development

As automation transforms industries, the demand for certain skills is changing. While some jobs may be displaced, others will be created, and many existing roles will require new skills and competencies. This shift presents both a challenge and an opportunity for Alberta's workforce.

One of the most effective ways to mitigate the impact of automation on job loss is through robust training programs designed to equip workers with the necessary skills to collaborate with advanced technologies12. Upskilling workers through training, AI, robotics, and computer vision ensures that they are equipped to adapt and thrive in the changing landscape of manufacturing automation12.

Alberta is facing a skills gap, with a growing need for workers with expertise in areas such as data analysis, AI, and automation technologies13. To address this gap, it is crucial to invest in workforce development and retraining programs that equip workers with the skills needed to thrive in the changing labor market. Fortunately, Alberta has a fast-growing, younger-than-average population, which provides an advantage in addressing this skills gap14.

Retraining Programs: Preparing for the Future of Work

Effective retraining programs are essential to ensure that workers can adapt to the challenges and opportunities of automation. These programs should focus on:

• Technical Skills: Providing training in areas such as AI, robotics, and automation technologies.

• Digital Literacy: Equipping workers with the skills to navigate and utilize digital tools and platforms.

• Critical Thinking and Problem-Solving: Developing skills that are essential for adapting to new technologies and work processes.

• Communication and Collaboration: Enhancing interpersonal skills that are crucial in a technologically driven workplace.

Successful Retraining Initiatives: Learning from Others

Several regions have implemented successful retraining programs to address the challenges of automation. These initiatives offer valuable lessons for Alberta:

• Amazon's Upskilling 2025: Amazon has committed significant resources to retrain its workforce, focusing on skills needed in areas such as technology and logistics15.

• Oregon's Hillsboro School District: This district has established early apprenticeships for high school students in advanced manufacturing, creating a pipeline of skilled workers16.

• Generation: This global organization operates training programs that target in-demand skills and demonstrate a strong return on investment for both learners and employers17.

Government Initiatives and Policies

The Alberta government has recognized the importance of addressing the impact of automation on the workforce. The "Alberta 2030: Building Skills for Jobs" strategy outlines a 10-year plan to advance skills and training needed for the province's economy18. This strategy emphasizes the need to build a highly skilled and competitive workforce, strengthen innovation, and forge stronger relationships between employers and post-secondary institutions.

This strategy acknowledges the challenges posed by rapid technological change and the growing skills gap18. It aims to ensure that Albertans are equipped with the skills and knowledge they need to succeed in a changing world of work.

However, there are calls for the government to do more to support job creation in diverse energy industries and to ensure a just transition for workers affected by automation19. This includes investing in clean energy technologies and providing support for communities traditionally reliant on the oil and gas sector.

The Role of Labor Unions and Organizations

Labor unions and other organizations play a crucial role in advocating for workers' rights and supporting them through the transition to an automated future. Unions can:

• Negotiate for job security and retraining opportunities: Unions can work with employers to ensure that automation is implemented in a way that minimizes job displacement and provides opportunities for workers to acquire new skills.

• Provide training and support: Unions can offer training programs and resources to help members adapt to new technologies and work processes.

• Advocate for policies that protect workers: Unions can lobby for government policies that support workers affected by automation, such as income support and retraining programs.

For example, the Canadian Union of Public Employees (CUPE) is actively engaged in addressing the challenges of AI in the workplace20. CUPE focuses on ensuring that workers have a voice in how AI systems are introduced and used, and advocates for collective agreements and laws that protect workers' rights and the quality of public services.

The Potential Benefits of Automation

While automation presents challenges, it also offers significant potential benefits for Alberta's economy. These include:

• Increased Productivity and Efficiency: Automation can streamline processes, reduce errors, and increase output, leading to greater efficiency and productivity21.

• Economic Growth: By improving productivity and reducing costs, automation can contribute to economic growth and create new opportunities in emerging sectors22.

• Improved Safety: Automation can remove workers from hazardous environments and reduce the risk of workplace injuries.

• Innovation: Automation can drive innovation and the development of new technologies, products, and services.

• Enhanced Quality of Life: By automating mundane and repetitive tasks, automation can free up employees to focus on more engaging and meaningful aspects of their work, potentially leading to increased job satisfaction and an improved quality of life22.

However, organizations also face challenges in implementing automation, such as:

• Cultural Resistance: Employees may be apprehensive about adopting new technologies due to fears of job loss or the complexities of new systems10.

• Regulatory Compliance: The integration of AI and automation in heavily regulated industries like oil and gas requires careful consideration of compliance requirements10.

Conclusion: Embracing the Future of Work

Automation is transforming the world of work, and Alberta must be prepared to navigate this technological shift. While there are concerns about job displacement, automation also presents opportunities for increased productivity, economic growth, and the creation of new jobs.

To ensure a successful transition, it is crucial to invest in workforce development and retraining programs, support workers affected by automation, and embrace the potential benefits of this technology. The Alberta government's "Alberta 2030: Building Skills for Jobs" strategy is a step in the right direction, but continued efforts are needed to ensure that all Albertans have the opportunity to thrive in an automated future.

Policymakers should consider targeted investments in skills development programs, particularly in areas such as AI, data analysis, and automation technologies. Incentives for businesses to adopt automation responsibly, while providing support for workers in transition, are also crucial. Collaboration between government, industry, labor unions, and educational institutions is essential to ensure a smooth transition and maximize the benefits of automation for all Albertans.

By proactively addressing the challenges and embracing the opportunities of automation, Alberta can position itself for continued economic growth and prosperity in the 21st century.

Works cited

1. A new study measures the actual impact of robots on jobs. It's significant. | MIT Sloan, accessed January 2, 2025, https://mitsloan.mit.edu/ideas-made-to-matter/a-new-study-measures-actual-impact-robots-jobs-its-significant

2. Understanding the impact of automation on workers, jobs, and wages - Brookings Institution, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/understanding-the-impact-of-automation-on-workers-jobs-and-wages/

3. Automation Trends Technical Talk Opportunities & Risks For Alberta - ISA Edmonton, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.isaedmonton.org/events-education/automation-trends-opportunities-risks-for-alberta/

4. Automation and Job Transformation in Canada: Who's at Risk?, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/11f0019m/11f0019m2020011-eng.htm

5. Importance: Alberta Centre for Labour Market Research, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.aclmr.ca/about/importance

6. The changing nature of work in Canada amid recent advances in automation technology, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www150.statcan.gc.ca/n1/pub/36-28-0001/2021001/article/00004-eng.htm

7. Job Creation or Job Loss? Big Companies Use Tax Cut to Automate ..., accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.parklandinstitute.ca/job_creation_or_job_loss

8. THE IMPACT OF AUTOMATION ON LOCAL COMMUNITIES: ECONOMIC FUTURES OF RURAL CANADA - Prentice Institute, accessed January 2, 2025, https://prenticeinstitute.ca/assets/volumes/pdf/prentice_presentation_automation_crrf.pdf?v=1690036265

9. Alberta well-positioned to deal with job losses from automation: study, accessed January 2, 2025, https://ca.news.yahoo.com/alberta-well-positioned-deal-job-130033023.html

10. AI and Automation in Traditional Industries, accessed January 2, 2025, https://calgaryindustry.ca/ai-and-automation-in-traditional-industries/

11. www.purestaffing.com, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.purestaffing.com/the-impact-of-ai-and-automation-on-canadas-skilled-trades-jobs/#:~:text=Job%20Displacement%20Concerns,-As%20AI%20and&text=Repetitive%20and%20manual%20tasks%2C%20such,were%20traditionally%20performed%20by%20humans.

12. Upskilling Workers Through Manufacturing Automation: Addressing Job Loss Concerns, accessed January 2, 2025, https://sciotex.com/upskilling-workers-through-manufacturing-automation-and-addressing-job-loss-concerns/

13. Labour and Skills Demand in Alberta - OECD, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.oecd.org/en/publications/labour-and-skills-demand-in-alberta_659ce346-en.html

14. Tackling Alberta's Skilled Labour Shortage, accessed January 2, 2025, https://albertaenterprisegroup.com/2023/12/05/tackling-albertas-skills-shortage/

15. Retraining as a Response to Automation — Promising, but Only if Done Right, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.skynettoday.com/overviews/upskilling

16. Laying the Groundwork: Strategies to mitigate automation's disruption potential | NC Commerce, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.commerce.nc.gov/news/the-lead-feed/laying-groundwork-strategies-mitigate-automations-disruption-potential

17. Retraining and reskilling workers in the age of automation - McKinsey, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.mckinsey.com/featured-insights/future-of-work/retraining-and-reskilling-workers-in-the-age-of-automation

18. Alberta 2030: Building Skills for Jobs Strategy - Open Government program, accessed January 2, 2025, https://open.alberta.ca/dataset/24e31942-e84b-4298-a82c-713b0a272604/resource/b5a2072e-8872-45f9-b84d-784d0e98c732/download/ae-alberta-2030-building-skills-for-jobs-10-year-strategy-post-secondary-education-2021-04.pdf

19. Alberta Government Needs to Do More to Support Job Creation in Diverse Energy Industries, accessed January 2, 2025, https://diversifyalberta.ca/alberta-government-needs-to-do-more-to-support-job-creation-in-diverse-energy-industries/

20. Understanding artificial intelligence: A guide for CUPE members, accessed January 2, 2025, https://cupe.ca/understanding-artificial-intelligence-guide-cupe-members

21. Unraveling the Impact of Automation: Separating Fact from Fiction ..., accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.serviceautomation.org/unraveling-the-impact-of-automation-separating-fact-from-fiction-on-job-loss/

22. Exploring the Effects of Automation on Employment - FMTalent, accessed January 2, 2025, https://www.fmtalent.com/insights-fm-talent/exploring-the-effects-of-automation-on-employment