The UCP's Wildfire Cuts and the Burning of Jasper: A Preventable Tragedy?

The devastating wildfire that swept through Jasper, Alberta in 2023 left a trail of destruction, raising questions about the role of the United Conservative Party (UCP) government in exacerbating the disaster. This article delves into the UCP's controversial cuts to Alberta's wildfire program and explores the potential link between these cuts and the extent of the damage suffered by the town of Jasper.

Alberta's Wildfire Program: Before and After the UCP

Before the UCP came into power in 2019, Alberta had a strong wildfire program. It was considered one of the best globally, with a network of lookout towers, a specialized aerial team, a well-funded air tanker program, and comprehensive training for rural firefighters 1. These elements enabled early detection and rapid response to wildfires, often preventing them from becoming large-scale disasters.

However, the UCP government, led by Premier Danielle Smith 2, implemented significant cuts to the wildfire program. These cuts are summarized in the table below:

Measure

Description

Impact

Closure of Fire Lookout Towers

26 fire towers shut down.

Reduced detection coverage by more than one-fifth, hindering early wildfire detection and response3.

Elimination of the Rappel Attack Program

The Wildland Firefighter Rappel Program, which deployed specialized firefighters to inaccessible areas, was eliminated.

Removed a critical resource for combating wildfires in challenging terrains3.

Reduction in Air Tanker Program

Funding for the air tanker program was reduced by 13%.

Limited crucial aerial support for wildfire suppression efforts1.

Cuts to Rural Firefighter Training

Training programs for rural firefighters were reduced.

Impacted the preparedness of local fire crews1.

Reduction in Wildfire Management Budget

The overall wildfire management budget was significantly reduced.

Decreased funding for wildfire management by approximately $30 million between 2018-2019 and 2023-20246.

In addition to the measures outlined above, the UCP government also significantly reduced the contingency fund for wildfire fighting. In the 2019-20 budget, this fund was around $485 million. However, it was reduced to $76 million in 2020-21, and while it increased slightly in subsequent years, it remained far below the 2019-20 level 6.

These cuts were widely criticized by firefighters, experts, and opposition parties, who warned that weakening Alberta's wildfire preparedness could have dire consequences 1. The government defended the elimination of the Rappel Attack Program, stating that it was based on "careful consideration" of the program's advantages, the types of wildfires Alberta has experienced, and those expected in the future. They argued that the crews were used for initial attack on less than 2% of Alberta's wildfires 7.

Historical Context of Wildfire Management in Alberta

Wildfire management in Alberta has a long and complex history. Before European settlement, Indigenous peoples used fire as a tool to shape the landscape and manage resources 8. They employed fire for various purposes, including clearing forests of fuel, promoting the growth of medicinal plants, and restoring habitat for wildlife. However, with European contact and the subsequent emphasis on resource extraction, traditional Indigenous fire management practices were suppressed, and fire came to be seen as a threat rather than a tool 8.

The 2023 Wildfire Season and the Jasper Disaster

The 2023 wildfire season in Alberta was one of the most severe on record, with over 1,000 fires burning nearly 3.3 million hectares of forest across the province 9. This was driven by a combination of factors, including unusually hot temperatures, low precipitation, and the presence of large amounts of dry and flammable vegetation 11. Climate change is also contributing to the increasing severity of wildfires in Canada, with studies showing an increase in the number of days conducive to high-severity fires 12.

Among the many fires that raged across Alberta in 2023, the wildfire that devastated the town of Jasper in July stands out. While the exact cause of the Jasper wildfire is unknown, experts believe that a combination of factors, including drought conditions, strong winds, and the presence of highly flammable dead trees from a previous mountain pine beetle infestation, contributed to its rapid spread and intensity 14. Key factors driving wildfires in the region include vapor pressure deficit, sea surface temperature, and maximum temperature 15.

The fire quickly engulfed the town 16, forcing the evacuation of all 5,000 residents and over 20,000 park visitors 17. Although no fatalities were reported, the fire caused significant structural damage, with estimates suggesting that 30-50% of the buildings in Jasper were potentially destroyed 2. The insured losses from the wildfire are estimated to be substantial, potentially exceeding $700 million 18. The wildfire also had a disproportionate impact on Indigenous communities, who often bear the brunt of such disasters 19.

Challenges in Containing the Jasper Wildfire

Containing the Jasper wildfire presented numerous challenges. Firefighting personnel were forced to relocate from Jasper to Hinton due to the fire's intensity and rapid spread, which was described as "a monster" by fire management officials 16. The fire damaged several bridges around the town and throughout the national park, further hindering access and firefighting efforts 20.

The unique characteristics of forest ecosystems in parks, including decades of fire suppression that have altered forest composition and increased vulnerability to wildfires, also posed challenges 21. Experts suggest that reversing these past practices and implementing proactive measures such as forest thinning are crucial to mitigating wildfire risks in protected areas 21.

Did the UCP's Cuts Contribute to the Jasper Disaster?

While it is impossible to definitively prove that the UCP's cuts directly caused the Jasper wildfire or the extent of its damage, several factors suggest that the cuts may have exacerbated the situation:

• Reduced Early Detection: The closure of fire lookout towers likely hindered early detection of the wildfire, potentially allowing it to grow unchecked for a crucial period before it could be investigated 3. This delay in response may have allowed the fire to gain intensity and spread more rapidly.

• Loss of Specialized Firefighting Capacity: The elimination of the Rappel Attack Program deprived firefighters of a crucial tool for combating wildfires in challenging terrains like those surrounding Jasper 3. This specialized team could have been instrumental in accessing and suppressing the fire in its early stages.

• Strain on Resources: The overall reduction in wildfire management funding and personnel likely strained resources and hampered the ability of firefighters to effectively respond to the large number of wildfires burning across the province in 2023 6. This may have limited the resources available to combat the Jasper wildfire.

Furthermore, experts have pointed out that the UCP government's focus on arson as a major cause of wildfires, while downplaying the role of climate change, may have hindered efforts to implement proactive mitigation strategies 22. This lack of focus on climate change adaptation could have left Alberta more vulnerable to the increasing frequency and severity of wildfires.

The Aftermath and the Future of Wildfire Management in Alberta

The Jasper wildfire served as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of wildfires and the importance of adequate preparedness. In the aftermath of the disaster, the Alberta government increased the wildfire budget by $55 million for the 2024 season and implemented new technologies such as drones, helicopters, and AI-powered thermal imaging to assist fire crews 23. The federal government also approved a request for assistance from Alberta, mobilizing resources and providing support to the province in its efforts to combat the wildfires 24.

However, critics argue that these measures are insufficient to address the damage caused by the previous cuts and the growing threat of wildfires due to climate change 23. The loss of experienced firefighters due to the UCP's cuts has created a gap in expertise that cannot be easily filled 7. This loss of experience, coupled with the increasing challenges posed by climate change-driven wildfires, raises concerns about the long-term effectiveness of Alberta's wildfire management program.

Recognizing the need to enhance wildfire response capacity, the federal and Alberta governments have jointly invested over $57 million over five years under the Fighting and Managing Wildfires in a Changing Climate Program – Equipment Fund (FMWCC) 25. This investment aims to support the purchase of essential wildfire equipment and the hiring and training of personnel.

Experts warn that 2024 could pose a significant wildfire risk, emphasizing the need for continued vigilance and preparedness 26. The Jasper wildfire also highlighted the need for a national wildfire strategy that brings together all levels of governance and stakeholders to effectively address the increasing challenges posed by wildfires in a changing climate 19.

Current Wildfire Situation in Alberta

As of January 4, 2025, Alberta has experienced 1,224 extinguished wildfires in the current year. There are currently no active wildfires within the Forest Protection Area, although this does not include carryover or mutual aid wildfires 27.

On-Ground Realities in Jasper

Recovery efforts are underway in Jasper, with a focus on restoring essential services and infrastructure. While the town and surrounding national park are open to visitors, some areas may still be affected by the wildfire 28. Realty and municipal services are gradually being restored, and residents are slowly returning to rebuild their lives and community. For up-to-date information on the situation in Jasper, please refer to official sources such as Parks Canada and the Municipality of Jasper.

Conclusion

The Jasper wildfire was a tragedy that had a profound impact on the community and raised serious questions about the adequacy of Alberta's wildfire management program. While the UCP government has taken some steps to address the situation, concerns remain about the long-term consequences of the cuts and the need for a more comprehensive and proactive approach to wildfire management in the face of a changing climate. The events in Jasper serve as a cautionary tale, highlighting the critical importance of investing in wildfire preparedness, retaining experienced firefighters, and acknowledging the role of climate change in exacerbating wildfire risks.

Synthesis of Findings

The UCP's cuts to the Alberta wildfire program, including the closure of fire lookout towers, the elimination of the Rappel Attack Program, and the reduction in the wildfire management budget, coincided with a period of increased wildfire activity in the province, culminating in the devastating Jasper wildfire of 2023. While a direct causal link is difficult to establish definitively, the cuts likely contributed to the severity of the disaster by hindering early detection, reducing specialized firefighting capacity, and straining resources. For example, the closure of fire lookout towers may have delayed the initial response to the Jasper wildfire, allowing it to grow unchecked and become more difficult to contain 3.

The Jasper wildfire underscores the need for increased investment in wildfire preparedness, a comprehensive national wildfire strategy, and a greater focus on climate change mitigation to address the growing threat of wildfires in Alberta and across Canada. Experts suggest that reversing past fire suppression practices, such as those that have altered forest ecosystems in national parks, is crucial to mitigating wildfire risks 21. Furthermore, the disproportionate impact of wildfires on Indigenous communities highlights the need for targeted support and resources to enhance their resilience and capacity to cope with such disasters 19.

Moving forward, Alberta needs to prioritize a multi-faceted approach to wildfire management that includes:

• Increased Investment: Adequate funding for wildfire prevention, preparedness, and response is essential. This includes restoring funding to previous levels and investing in new technologies and resources.

• Enhanced Training and Retention: Recruiting, training, and retaining experienced firefighters is crucial for effective wildfire management. This includes providing competitive salaries and benefits to attract and retain skilled personnel.

• Climate Change Adaptation: Integrating climate change considerations into wildfire management strategies is critical. This includes proactive measures such as forest thinning and fuel management to reduce wildfire risks.

• Collaboration and Coordination: Effective wildfire management requires collaboration and coordination among all levels of government, Indigenous communities, and other stakeholders. This includes developing a comprehensive national wildfire strategy that addresses the challenges posed by climate change.

By learning from the Jasper wildfire and implementing these recommendations, Alberta can better protect its communities and natural resources from the increasing threat of wildfires.

Works cited

1. Provincial government bears responsibility for Jasper wildfire : r ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.reddit.com/r/alberta/comments/1ecay6o/provincial_government_bears_responsibility_for/

2. Jasper wildfire has caused '30 to 50 per cent structural damage,' says Alberta premier, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cWglR8y-b3Y

3. 'A skeleton crew': UCP cuts led to Alberta wildfire disaster | The ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://thenarwhal.ca/alberta-wildfire-ucp-cuts/

4. UCP Gutted Firefighter Programs - Project Calgary, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.projectcalgary.org/ucp_gutted_firefighter_programs

5. Alberta gov't must reverse UCP cuts to wildfire fighting operations ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.aupe.org/news/news-and-updates/alberta-govt-must-reverse-ucp-cuts-wildfire-fighting-operations

6. Alberta's UCP Government Has Cut Tens of Millions of Dollars From ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://pressprogress.ca/albertas-ucp-government-has-cut-tens-of-millions-of-dollars-from-wildfire-preparedness-programs/

7. Wildfire Mitigation Strategies for Alberta | Alberta Land Institute, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.ualberta.ca/en/alberta-land-institute/news/2024/08-august/wildfire-mitigation-strategies-for-alberta.html

8. Wildfire Management in the Province of Alberta, Canada: Then, Now and the Future | Open Case Studies - The University of British Columbia, accessed January 4, 2025, https://cases.open.ubc.ca/wildfire-management-in-the-province-of-alberta-canada-then-now-and-the-future/

9. Effects of 2023 Wildfires in Alberta, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.cclmportal.ca/resource/effects-2023-wildfires-alberta

10. Effects of 2023 Wildfires in Alberta, accessed January 4, 2025, https://ftp-public.abmi.ca/home/publications/documents/642_ABMI_2024_EffectsOf2023WildfiresInAlberta_ScienceLetter_Issue8.pdf

11. Canada's Record-Breaking 2023 Wildfires Released Nearly 4 Times More Carbon than Global Aviation - World Resources Institute, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.wri.org/insights/canada-wildfire-emissions

12. Canada primed for more severe wildfire days, driven by dry forest fuel: Study - Global News, accessed January 4, 2025, https://globalnews.ca/news/10940334/canada-climate-wildfire-severity/

13. Alberta's 2023 wildfires: context, factors, and futures - Canadian Science Publishing, accessed January 4, 2025, https://cdnsciencepub.com/doi/10.1139/cjfr-2024-0099

14. Jasper Wildfire the Start of "More Extreme Fires" - Alberta Views, accessed January 4, 2025, https://albertaviews.ca/more-extreme-fires/

15. Driving Factors and Future Trends of Wildfires in Alberta, Canada - MDPI, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.mdpi.com/2571-6255/7/11/419

16. Wildfires Ravage Jasper, Marmot Basin Evacuated - Ski Area ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.saminfo.com/news/sam-headline-news/wildfires-ravage-jasper-marmot-basin-evacuated

17. 'Monster' wildfire devastates historic Canadian resort town - BBC News, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.bbc.com/news/live/cgerp77q1ynt

18. Insured losses from Jasper wildfire surpass $880 million, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.ibc.ca/news-insights/news/insured-losses-from-jasper-wildfire-surpass-880-million

19. Jasper fire is a grim reminder of the urgency of adopting a national ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.queensu.ca/gazette/stories/jasper-fire-grim-reminder-urgency-adopting-national-wildfire-strategy

20. Jasper wildfire: Why rebuilding Alberta town may be 'logistical ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://globalnews.ca/news/10643691/jasper-wildfire-rebuilding-challenges/

21. Jasper wildfire: why are Canada's parks so primed to burn? | The Narwhal, accessed January 4, 2025, https://thenarwhal.ca/jasper-wildfire-canada-parks-change/

22. Alberta Premier Danielle Smith Still Won't Mention Wildfire Links to ..., accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.desmog.com/2024/08/08/alberta-premier-danielle-smith-still-wont-mention-wildfire-links-to-climate-change/

23. Wildfire Mitigation Strategies for Alberta: News - Alberta Land Institute, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.albertalandinstitute.ca/news/post/wildfire-mitigation

24. Statement from Minister Sajjan regarding the wildfires situation in Alberta - Canada.ca, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.canada.ca/en/public-safety-canada/news/2024/07/statement-from-minister-sajjan-regarding-the-wildfires-situation-in-alberta.html

25. Canada and Alberta Announce Major Investment to Purchase More Wildfire Equipment, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.canada.ca/en/natural-resources-canada/news/2024/08/canada-and-alberta-announce-major-investment-to-purchase-more-wildfire-equipment.html

26. Alberta's wildfire season: Insurance experts share tips to stay safe and protect your property, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.ibc.ca/news-insights/news/albertas-wildfire-season:-insurance-experts-share-tips-to-stay-safe-and-protect-your-property

27. Alberta Wildfire Status Dashboard Tablet, accessed January 4, 2025, https://www.arcgis.com/apps/dashboards/8d86d267dcf44ad085a11939186f3d3a

28. Fire information and updates - Jasper National Park - Parks Canada, accessed January 4, 2025, https://parks.canada.ca/pn-np/ab/jasper/visit/feu-alert-fire